How To Implement a Crime When Writing a Mystery Novel

When something is easy, most people say that it’s just like “taking candy from a baby.” Of course taking candy from a young child is easy because they can’t really fight back. You run away, they cry. Nothing else can really get done about it.

But if you’re going to rob someone there needs to be a bit more planning to it than just grabbing it right under the person’s nose and running away.

And no, I’m not talking about stealing from people in real life because that would just be wrong. But if you’re going to have a robbery, or any crime, in your mystery novel then you need to know how to implement it.

How To Implement a crime when writing a mystery novel Rachel Poli

Research is important to any novel, any genre. However, there’s a lot of information that goes into writing mystery.

You have the law, the law enforcement, and all the many different kinds of crimes as well as what their consequences are.

The Law

Whether you’re following the law or breaking it, the law is still there. You can’t see it, you can’t hear it, but it is there.

If your characters do something illegal, someone is bound to find out. Someone is bound to catch up to them. They are bound to be punished for it.

Here is where the setting of your story really comes into play. Most mystery novels are based off actual cities and towns.

If your novel takes place in Texas, then you need to know the laws specific to Texas. Each state is different, each country is different.

If you don’t know the laws of where you live, then Google is your friend. As well as your library or Town Hall.

Law Enforcement

What exactly does the chief of police do? What exactly do the coroners do with the dead bodies behind those four walls? How do detectives investigate? How do prosecutors and defense attorneys figure out their information? Do we even need to go to court? Can we go straight to jail?

I hate to break it to you, but you can’t just have a character point to another character and say, “He did it!” Then the other guy hangs his head sadly and says, “Well, you got me…”

If that was the case, I’m pretty sure crime would be non-existent at this point.


When I was writing George Florence I didn’t bother to do any research about actually killing someone because I just wanted to get the first draft written, the idea out of my head.

So during the editing process, I researched strangulation. I have to say that I learned quite a lot. I probably learned more information than I needed to know.

However, I very quickly learned that I wrote the entire scene wrong. Strangling someone is not as simple as choking someone and not allowing them to breath. I learned a lot about it from a medical standpoint as well as the anatomy of it all.

I haven’t rewritten the scene yet, but I’m sure it’ll be much better and way more accurate than before.

The Research

As stated earlier, Google and the library are your friends. Well, guess what? So am I!

So here are a few resources I’ve found along the way that I really think are great and I hope you do too.


1. Book of Poisons: A Guide for Writers by Serita Stevens
2. Forensics: A Guide for Writers by D.P. Lyle
3. Police Procedure & Investigation: A Guide for Writers by Lee Lofland
4. Now Write! Mysteries by Sherry Ellis and Laurie Lamson

Of course, read all the mystery novels you can find and learn from those. Even true crime novels would have a lot of information.


1. Writing World — This website is packed with writing information in general, but here’s the mystery section.
2. Research Resources for Mystery and Crime Writers — This article has a ton of other links to great research sites.
3. Research for Mystery Novels — This article is from Mystery Month last year. I was looking for the websites I usually go on and when I Googled something, this post was on the first page. I decided to put it on the list mostly because I was impressed and proud that out of 27 millions results, one of my articles was number six.

I thought I had more websites than that, but I’ll add to it as I find more. Apparently I use books for most of my research. Look at me going old school instead of asking Google everything!

How do you research for your mystery cases or your other novels?

rachel poli sign off

Twitter | Tumblr | Pinterest | GoodReads

Mystery Month 2016

Last year I celebrated the Mystery genre on my blog during the month of June.

My audience responded well with it and I had a lot of fun with it, so I decided to bring it back!

Mystery Month June 2016 Rachel Poli

During the month of June, I’ll be focusing more so on the mystery genre as that’s mainly what I write about.

I will continue my regular features such as Short Story Sunday, Time to Write, and my book reviews. Short Story Sunday will be a four-part mystery short story. The Time to Write prompts will be four mini prompts to help you write your own mystery.

Last year for my book reviews I read mystery books. I’ve been getting a lot of author requests to review their books, so that didn’t work out this year. However, some of the book reviews will have mystery elements to them.

I’m not going to write mystery related articles every single day because I have other things to talk about and touch upon (Camp NaNo next month… a readathon… etc…). With that being said, I have seven dates when I’ll post mystery related articles.

The posts will be as follows:

June 7 — Ingredients for Mystery Soup
June 8 — How To Plan a Crime
June 9 — How to Implement a Crime
June 13 — 8 Types of Mystery Subgenres
June 15 — 10 Cliches in Mystery Novels
June 20 — Mystery is a Mystery
June 22 — How To Begin Your Mystery Novel

That’s Mystery Month for 2016! I already got a head start on writing the articles and I have to say that I’ve been having fun with it as well as learning a lot.

I hope the same for all of you!

rachel poli sign off

Twitter | Tumblr | Pinterest | GoodReads

June 2016 Goals


Here are the books I will be reading and reviewing this month. The list may change.

1. The Secrets of Ice Cream Success by AD Hartley
2. Murder House by James Patterson
3. Campion’s Choice (Or How to Take a Picture of the Future) by Geoff Warwick
4. The Reflections of Queen Snow White by David Meredith


1. Edit George Florence (June 1-June 15)
2. Edit The Lost Girl (June 16-June 30)
3. Outline Camp NaNo novel — Please vote for which novel I should write in July’s Camp NaNo session!


1. Write July posts
2. Follow new blogs and comment a lot

June is going to be a busy month, but I think I’m well prepared for it.

What are your goals for June?

rachel poli sign off

Twitter | Tumblr | Pinterest | GoodReads